My daughter and her husband have been having problems for quite a while. In fact, he says he hasn’t felt right about them for 3 years. (They are married 6+). My husband and I have stayed out of it, unless she asks for help. They still live together, but more or less as roommates. He doesn’t know what he wants. He finally has agreed to counseling, but they haven’t started yet. Last night, my daughter called and asked what we were doing about Father’s Day, saying she’d like her husband included in our family plans. We have not spoken to him for months and we are devastated at how he is treating her. We really do not want to be around him right now. My daughter thinks we should put her feelings before our own because we are the parent and children should come first. When we were raising our children, they were put first before our own needs, but as an adult that does not apply. We will support her any way we can and hopefully in the future, we will be able to have a relationship with our son-in-law. But there is just too much pain and hurt to want to have him as part of family functions. Are we wrong for feeling this way?
Dear Concerned Parent,
They may not still be together come Father’s Day, as that will be six months off. I don’t agree that adult children should always be put first, but this conflict isn’t really about that. It’s about conveying to your daughter that you accept her as a person in her own right. That you believe in her, even when she’s not sure she believes in herself. She’s the only one who can decide if her marriage is working for her, not you.
You love your daughter and you want the best for her. That means you need to follow her lead in this. As parents, we’re always working our way out of a job. We encourage them and try to teach our children what they need to be strong adults, so let her do that here. She’s in an unhappy situation with her husband and, as difficult as that is to watch, you have to take the back seat on this one.
Unless her husband has physically attacked her or you–or stolen from you–you have to let her decide what family functions to include him in. Whatever she does with the marriage is her decision. You may be disappointed in your son-in-law. You might have felt close to him, but are now repulsed by who he’s shown himself to be. It’s still her call whether she continues to be married to him or not.
In the past, my husband and I talked of traveling over the Christmas holidays so we wouldn’t have to deal with our troubled children and their troubled relationships. We didn’t end up doing this, but I very much understand your desire to avoid interacting with your son-in-law. You need to suck it up, however. Smile at him and sincerely wish him to find whatever he needs. Even if you don’t like him–or he doesn’t seem to like you–hope for his learning.
You didn’t want your parents deciding who you should or shouldn’t be with. Now it’s time to let your daughter make her big decisions.